Solving the Edge Webdriver Conundrum: A Guide to Using “–guest” and “download.default_directory” Options

If you’re an automation enthusiast or a QA engineer, you’re no stranger to the world of webdrivers. Edge Webdriver, in particular, has become a popular choice for automating Microsoft Edge browsers. However, when it comes to using the “–guest” and “download.default_directory” options together, things can get a bit tricky. In this article, we’ll delve into the reasons behind this limitation and provide a clear set of instructions to help you overcome this hurdle.

The Problem: Incompatible Options

When you try to use both the “–guest” and “download.default_directory” options simultaneously, you might encounter an error message or unstable behavior. This is because these options are mutually exclusive, and Edge Webdriver simply can’t reconcile their conflicting requirements.

What do these options do?

To understand why these options are incompatible, let’s take a closer look at what each one does:

• --guest: This option launches Edge in guest mode, which means that all browsing data, including cookies, history, and extensions, is discarded at the end of the session. This mode is useful for testing scenarios that require a clean slate.
• download.default_directory: This option specifies the default directory where Edge saves downloaded files. By setting this option, you can control the download location and organize your files more efficiently.

Why can’t they coexist?

The reason behind the incompatibility lies in the way Edge Webdriver handles these options. When you use the “–guest” option, Edge Webdriver creates a temporary user profile, which is discarded at the end of the session. This temporary profile doesn’t allow for persistent settings, including the download directory.

On the other hand, the “download.default_directory” option relies on the persistence of the user profile to store the download location. Since the “–guest” option creates a temporary profile, the download directory setting is lost when the session ends.

Solutions: Workarounds and Alternatives

Don’t worry, all hope is not lost! We’ve got some clever workarounds and alternatives to help you achieve your automation goals:

1. Use a Temporary Directory

You can create a temporary directory for downloads and set it as the default directory using the download.default_directory option. This way, you can still control the download location without conflicting with the “–guest” option.

from selenium import webdriver

options = webdriver.EdgeOptions()
options.add_argument("--guest")
options.add_argument("download.default_directory=C:/temp/downloads")

driver = webdriver.Edge(options=options)

2. Implement a Custom Download Handler

Another approach is to create a custom download handler that can intercept and redirect downloads to a specific directory. This way, you can bypass the limitations of the download.default_directory option.

from selenium import webdriver

class CustomDownloadHandler:
    def __init__(self, download_directory):
        self.download_directory = download_directory

    def before_download(self, request):
        request.set_download_path(self.download_directory)

options = webdriver.EdgeOptions()
options.add_argument("--guest")

driver = webdriver.Edge(options=options)
download_handler = CustomDownloadHandler("C:/temp/downloads")
driver.execute_script("window Downloads.onBeforeDownload = function(request) {{ return {} }}")
driver.execute_script("window Downloads.onDownload = function(request) {{ {} }}")
driver.execute_script("window Downloads.onDownloadComplete = function(request) {{ {} }}")
driver.execute_script("window Downloads.onDownloadCancelled = function(request) {{ {} }}")

3. Use an Alternative WebDriver

If you’re not tied to Edge Webdriver, you can explore alternative webdrivers that don’t have these limitations. For example, ChromeDriver or FirefoxDriver might be suitable alternatives, depending on your testing requirements.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the incompatibility of the “–guest” and “download.default_directory” options in Edge Webdriver is a limitation that can be overcome with some creativity and flexibility. By using temporary directories, implementing custom download handlers, or exploring alternative webdrivers, you can still achieve your automation goals.

Takeaway Table

Solution	Description	Advantages	Disadvantages
Temporary Directory	Set a temporary directory for downloads	Easy to implement, flexible	Requires cleanup, might not be suitable for large-scale testing
Custom Download Handler	Intercept and redirect downloads to a specific directory	Provides fine-grained control, flexible	Requires programming effort, might be complex to implement
Alternative WebDriver	Use a different webdriver that doesn’t have these limitations	Wide range of options, might be more suitable for certain testing scenarios	Requires switching to a different webdriver, might require adjustments to existing tests

By understanding the limitations and trade-offs of each solution, you can make an informed decision that best suits your automation needs. Happy testing!

Frequently Asked Question

Get answers to the most pressing Edge WebDriver conundrums!